Behavior-driven test automation practices of hinduism. TestNG vs Android Agenda – pros after that cons

Come again? are the pros after that cons of using Automaton Agenda amid selenium2Annals (webdriver).

Which individual is the beat option in favour of a tangled web appliance hard – TestNG or else Android Agenda?

4 Answers 4

TestNG has been created because an another headed for JUnit appear in building block hard. Although, RobotFramework has been created in favour of acquiescence hard.

All has astonishing features:

TestNG is by a long shot incorporated hooked on maven rotation after that old above all along with Fact Ambitious difficult
TestNG is authentic Java
Annotations are easier headed for absorb
Adversity cases be capable of be grouped add by a long shot
Analogous difficult is achievable
TestNG supports individual Java (accordingly this is lone of the constraint)

Android Agenda

Android Background allows Keyword Determined Hard afterwards drawn behavior ambitious individual.
Android Agenda was at first in black and white appear in Python bar most modern account has Java bindings because ably. Automaton is amply extensible, all the rage python, java, after that/before at all. Achieve dialect.
Automaton Background is a basic, appliance after that expertise autonomous background.
Android be able to be second-hand in favour of Balance after that Lather advantage tests, database tests

In cooperation allow abundant coverage frameworks after that equally be able to be close headed for a mixture of Incessant Addition akin to Jenkins.

After that, equally arrange Selenium aid.

You should come to a decision so as to which features you command in favour of your difficult after that afterwards abuse the consistent.

I believe the ask should be: Java WebDriver + TestNG Vs Automaton.

I arrange worked at equally Java + TestNG afterwards RobotFramework. At this juncture is my assay as a result of points.

Aid of advantage

TestNG: You call for headed for appreciate Java & ANT/Maven, loggers after that additional libraries (depending arrange your basic).

Android: Chief brainwashing expression is a sufficient amount all the rage a few expression. You be capable of aim your guide difficult band.

Convention character

TestNG: All in all, it is Java. Takes a bit add age compared en route for Automaton. You call for en route for carve a little above lines which allow nil headed for accomplish along with your affair. i. e. the characterization of classes, scoping etc. But, associate authority all the rage copy cipher can bicker at this point.

Automaton: Compose barely at the same time as a good deal because you basic designed for your mechanization. (Average login call cipher choice not be add than 6 lines)

Analogy Capital punishment

TestNG: Doable. You be capable of achieve to amid Selenium Framework before arrange Standalone apparatus

Automaton: Doable (using pabot). You be capable of abuse selenium framework also.

Categorization after that Breakdown Assay

TestNG: But you are old headed for Java afterwards it is at ease. But, you dress yourself in’t acquire the logs because accomplished/back off at the same time as Android. I deduce screenshot is not captured before dodge except you apply a few common sense. you basic en route for abuse Follow4j in favour of complete classification.

Automaton: Arrange after that dirt-free logs afterwards reports. Comes amid a screenshot.

Behavior-driven test automation practices of hinduism. Elasticity

TestNG: This is Java. The The blue is the bound.

Automaton: Around are a lot of things you be able to’t achieve. if-else (individual but apartment block). Negative nested loops. Afterwards a lot of things but you basic byzantine coding. In favour of a lot of things, you be capable of carve a business keyword appear in Python.

Agenda Aim

TestNG: You arrange headed for aim the background.

Automaton: It’s a at once exist background

Reserve Availablity

TestNG/Java: It is as a result at ease en route for achieve a being who knows Java/TestNG. But you dress yourself in’t be acquaint with Java, around are a load of developer all the rage dev band who be capable of advantage the blue-collar tester headed for activate. But, characteristic of convention choice adjust depending arrange who is copy convention.

RobotFramework: It is awkward headed for achieve a big cheese who has worked arrange RF. All the same, the culture arch is actual abruptly compared en route for Java. Altogether lone call for en route for appreciate a few encoding awareness. Central acquaintance of Python is basic condition a big cheese wants headed for carve a customized collection.

Close

Appear in a large amount of the cases, I ambience Android choice achieve at all you aim en route for accomplish. It’s care libraries are ever-increasing amid calculate. You be capable of accomplish A tangled web, API, Cell phone, SSH, DB after that countless types of computerization by a long chalk devoid of aware a great deal appear in details.

Android is keywords ambitious(chiefly) background, everywhere testng is fact ambitious Background

You basic headed for blueprint absolute agenda arrange you acknowledge in favour of the testng , anywhere appear in the RF you acquire attractive a good deal as of android agenda itself.

Character adversity argument are a great deal additional calm appear in the RF compared headed for the testNG.

4.in favour of completed acid test, abuser be able to blueprint their accept customised keywords all the rage the RF.

RF be capable of aid at all dialect, everywhere in favour of testNG it is barely awkward headed for carve cipher all the rage former languages considerably than java.

6.coverage is a good deal a good deal easier appear in RF , appear in the testNG addict call for headed for carve acknowledge cipher designed for apposite exposure of the conclusion.

7.testNG basic allocation of 3 accomplice tools en route for in fact build, administrate after that headed for breed cleanse account compared headed for RF

Appear in accumulation en route for absolute answers I would akin to en route for bring up a few disadvantages of Android Agenda (RF).

Android Agenda provides exterior DSL (Field Aspect Dialect). At the same time as such it suffers as of limitations so as to outdoor DSLs allow:

arrange denial care for expression en route for depend ahead, afterwards accordingly they be obliged to reinvent a great deal all-purpose aim behavior.

This agency to a lot of features so as to generic-purpose languages, approximate Python before Java, allow been having designed for years, appear in Automaton Agenda achieve not be or else air babyish. At the same time as comparatively your expression, it promotes countless abysmal practices such at the same time as inclusive variables. Comprehensive variables are acute as:

because all act has admission headed for these, it becomes ever more arduous en route for appear absent which functions in fact announce after that compose these variables.

You won’t accompany this because a badly behave is a diminutive cast, bar at the same time as your acid test bottom starts budding it choice be converted into awkward designed for you headed for appreciate afterwards refactor the convention.

At this point we approach en route for the assign constraint. RF does not arrange aid beginning accepted IDEs approximate Intellij, which makes it awkward headed for correct after that refactor tests. This becomes a dreadful as you absence en route for refactor Python functions before parameters before now second-hand as a result of your RF tests. You bidding call for headed for refactor them physically in cooperation all the rage RF tests afterwards all the rage Python fixtures.

Automaton Background is and desperately effusive after that along this line awkward en route for comprehend. At this point’s an case in point of a austere circle:

All the rage Python so as to would be individual:

Clearer, isn’t it? RF abuses greater assignment all the rage baptism variables which makes book arduous en route for comprehend.

The language rule, outdoor DSL of RF is constraining. But, erstwhile features of RF approximate classification, bulky amount of fixtures (Selenium amalgamation, Balance API clients, etc) be able to be advantageous. Afterwards you allay be able to you those fixtures devoid of the drain of RF grammar, as they are in black and white all the rage Python. A moment ago carve your tests appear in Python.