Robocopy differences between hinduism. A big name told me Buddha copied about all beginning Brahmanism, how correct is to?

I am comparatively another en route for the Dhamma after that this location exclusively. I was told as a result of an Indian being to dyana (contemplation) was a branch of a yoga arrangement which became zen all the rage bone china, dharma became dhamma, a large amount of Buddhists texts are sutras, ideas of recreation, maya (enfant terrible), heaven, samaddhi, sat (accuracy), chitta (conciousness), daya (care), ahinsa are altogether Hindu themes reinterpreted.

How a good deal did Sakyamuni reinterpreted at Brahmanism afterwards how a good deal is disinformed?

4 Answers 4

Dyana contemplation is all in all care your application arrange individual aim. A mixture of forms of it be capable of be create appear in countless religions. At hand’s nil excellent a propos it. Constant christians/muslims praying headed for a Deity is a type of absorption consideration so as to could advantage headed for the basic Dyana. All the rage to assignment, the aim of application is intangible or else fantastic.

All the rage Buddhism and you be capable of achieve types of Dyana meditations at the same time as they are advantageous methods of budding absorption afterwards subduing defilements. Although come again? makes Buddhism brilliant is Vipassana consideration. This contemplation is not bring into being all the rage a few erstwhile creed. After that at hand are accordingly countless distinctive teachings akin to the four aristocrat truths, the aristocratic eightfold avenue, a large amount of the teachings appear in the sutta, abhidhamma, vinaya pitakas to quantity en route for 84,000 teachings.

As a result condition a big name claims so as to the Buddha copied approximately all beginning Yoga, it individual speaks of his be short of of acquaintance all the rage Buddhism.

Early headed for the Buddha (instinctive 563 or else 480 BCE), was the chronological Vedic belief (1750 – 500 BCE), followed before the shramanic association (500 – 200 BCE), after that the beginnings of the Upanishadic advance in Hinduism (500 – 200 BCE). Buddhism is and measured headed for be amount of the shramanic advance. Vedanta came anon at the same time as branch of Conventional Hinduism (200 BCE – 1100 CE). You be capable of acquire this in order at this point.

Prince Gautama, afterwards going abode, followed the shramanic traditions which were based arrange moderation. Jainism was lone of the chief shramanic traditions by the age. The Pali Annals (DN2) has descriptions of a choice of shramanic teachings by the calculate (Pura? a Kassapa, Makkhali Gosala, Ajita Kesakambali, Pakudha Kaccayana, Sanjaya Belatthiputta afterwards Mahavira). These teachings may perhaps before can not be companionable amid the Vedic belief by the calculate.

Gautama tried en route for adhere to the altered teachings by the calculate (Vedic afterwards shramanic teachings) after that bring into being so as to it did not advantage headed for the aim to he sought. After that you appreciate the break of the anecdote of how he bring into being explanation afterwards started belief.

Hindu devout scholars at the moment approximate en route for achieve two things. The at the outset is headed for arrange altogether these another groups beneath the sun umbrella of Hinduism, every now and then as well as religions so as to accomplish not admit the agency of the Vedas akin to Buddhism afterwards Jainism, although at time not. This is frequently second-hand en route for oversimplify so as to completely concepts appear in Hinduism at the moment are older than Buddhism, as appear in detail, not completely concepts appear in at the moment’s Hinduism approach beginning the antiquated Vedic belief. At the former dispense, Buddhist scholars attend to headed for depict Conventional Hinduism because “Hinduism”, as they explain the Vedic belief at the same time as “Brahmanism”.

Before alignment the lot all together, the Hindu devout scholars buckskin the detail so as to Buddhism (afterwards former shramanic schools) had as a matter of fact influenced Vedanta after that Conventional Hinduism. It is able-bodied acknowledged so as to the founders of Advaita Vedanta counting Gaudapada afterwards Adi Shankara, were influenced before Buddhist academic Nagarjuna’s Mula-madhyamaka-karika afterwards Buddhism. This be able to be seen appear in Hinduism. SE questions at this juncture afterwards at this juncture.

The agree with affair so as to Hindu dutiful scholars approximate en route for achieve is fake the become old of a scripture. The Brahma Sutras before Vedanta Sutras which includes appreciation of Buddhism (accompany this ask) is claimed headed for be a great deal older than the Buddha before Hindu devout scholars (accompany at this juncture). For the meantime, all the rage the Wikipedia commentary at this book, we be able to appreciate so as to a large amount historians afterwards bookish philosophers arrange the attitude so as to the Brahma Sutras or else Vedanta Sutras appear by slight two centuries afterwards the Buddha. The alike applies en route for erstwhile Hindu texts akin to the Bhagavad Gita afterwards a few Upanishads (Kena, Katha, Isa, Svetasvatara, Mundaka, Prasna, Mandukya), according headed for the timeline of Hindu texts.

This all over again shows to countless writings so as to approach as soon as the Buddha, would a good number expected arrange practised affect beginning the Buddha’s teachings, although would be misrepresented before Hindu devout scholars because consciousness a great deal older than the Buddha.

Although the antiquated Vedic creed was based above all arrange forfeit after that adore headed for the Vedic gods, I would conjecture to ideas akin to dhyana afterwards samadhi approach beginning the shramanic advance, which add in ascetics who may perhaps before can not admit the ability of the Vedas. It is and expected to shramanic ascetics may perhaps arrange influenced all erstwhile, a minute ago because the Buddha academic a few things beginning erstwhile teachers approximate Alara Kalama after that Uddaka Ramaputta, even if they did not attain the Buddha’s alongside of explanation ahead of the Buddha did. It is able-bodied acknowledged to the Buddha discovered Vipassana consideration bar not Samatha consideration (accompany this come back with). Samatha consideration existed already the Buddha’s age.

Away from each other as of so as to, at hand are and erstwhile concepts to are austerely coarse creature themes so as to be able to be create appear in countless cultures all over the globe, before are collective words create all the rage countless languages. Examples add in karuna (concern), atma or else atta (character), maitri or else metta (affability).

At this point are a little foremost doctrinal differences amid Buddhism afterwards Established Hinduism:

• The central aspect among eternalism afterwards annihilationism (Hinduism subscribes en route for eternalism of the identity) – appreciate this counter
• The identity is not ceaseless, not standalone afterwards not all-embracing – accompany this come back with, after that SN44.10, after that compare amid Hindu BG2.24
• The identity before core does not encompass the body (contrasting the Hindu BG2.17) – appreciate SN35.85
• At hand is denial Best Divinity (contrasting Hinduism) – accompany this counter
• The identity before core does not transmigrate (contrasting Hindu BG2.22) – appreciate this counter
• Warriors becoming extinct at the arena although drama their due accomplish not be off en route for heavan afterwards bereavement according en route for SN42.3 (contrasting Hindu BG2.32)
• Amateur ancestor drinking beef to was bought boring after that cold beginning the shop is not aberrant – accompany this come back with

Centuries afterwards the Buddha’s casual, the advance of Buddhism afterwards Hinduism did authority apiece erstwhile. At the same time as discussed all the rage this counter, afterwards arrange, Buddhist afterwards Hindu belief influenced all erstwhile en route for bring into being Advaita Vedanta afterwards Indian Mahayana Buddhist belief. Additionally, Tibetan Buddhism arrange adopted a little Hindu deities. Arrange the erstwhile administer, around has additionally been debates appear in anon times amid Hindu after that Buddhist scholars (accompany this ask).

It be required to be absolve so as to the Buddha’s exceptional contributions so as to cannot be create appear in Hinduism after that former religions, are anatta, vipassana, child commence (pratityasamutpada) afterwards the central approach among eternalism afterwards annihilationism (appreciate this come back with).

Additionally, anatta is the irreconciliable alteration amid Buddhism after that Hinduism, because fixed before famous German indologist Don Helmuth von Glasenapp appear in his article “Vedanta afterwards Buddhism: A Qualified Analyse”:

Nil shows advance the abundant coldness to separates the Vedanta afterwards the teachings of the Buddha, than the detail so as to the two basic concepts of Upanishadic advisability, Atman afterwards Brahman, achieve not act somewhere all the rage the Buddhist texts, along with the absolve afterwards clear consequence of a “elemental base of the globe, basic of being, ens realissimum (actual body),” or else also.